The BackRow Ballers are no longer lowly medical students, blogging about the daily grind. They are now doctors, who will continue to bring light, joy, sunshine to their readers' lives with their blogs. You're welcome.

Tuesday, April 15, 2008

Am I a White Person?

If you are my friend, here is what a typical interaction consists of:

Mariam: Hello infidel white person!
Jack: You are as close to a non-white person I've ever gotten! Saracens aren't too bad, I guess.

Or something like this:
Mariam: When I was growing up, amongst white folk, and I was the only brown person, and my mom made me kabab sandwiches instead of turkey, it was really hard on me. Yay Pakistanis!
Abby: I'm a WASP, and I went to Lehigh, where diversity goes to die.
Sarah: I am figuratively and literally very white.

I also enjoy saying things like, "I had one white friend in college. She was a cheerleader in high school!" as if the latter fact is some affirmation that she was a normal, mainstream white person American. And so, the bottom line is this: my day consists of reaffirming white people's whiteness, and my own difference as a brown person infiltrating this hegemonic whiteness. I.e. I am so foreign, so different, so exotic, look at me, I had weird experiences with immigrant parents and strange, smelly foods.

Many people who are foreign but very assimilated spend time telling me that I am not foreign because I was born in America (Granite City, IL, which could possibly about as middle-America as you can get). People like Shlee, who is Persian, but considers himself an American, say things like: "I am not foreign. For example, my girlfriend is white." I think that's excellent that Shlee is doing well for himself in America, but if I were a white person, I would look at his dark hair and beard and think, not American! Maybe that's just me, though.

Anyway, one day, my entire identity was called into question. Last week, I stumbled onto a really cool blog called Stuff White People Like after reading about it in the New York Times. Mocking whitness was a clever idea, but then, things took a very dark and sinister turn. I realized I liked 41 out of the 95 top things white people liked.

This seemed excessive so I asked Jemily, my favorite medical school power couple. Emily cheerfully told me not to worry - the blog was mocking her, too! Easy for you to say, you are white, I thought meanly. Jack argued that these were merely "people interests." I personally thought that of course, he would think this - white males always tend to think that the their interests are the world's interests.

An identity crisis ensued. I prided myself on not being mainstream - I even stated as much on my Facebook profile. I was proud of my varied, decidedly unique interests (David Sedaris, English lit, Michael Gondry, Whole Foods, incidentally all things on said list). And I was proud of my ethnic heritage - always showing off about being Pakistani to make white people aware of their own inherent homogeneity. And ironically, this, too, was on the list. The blog made me realize not only that I wasn't very unique, but that I was almost a parody of the typical, upper-middle class, educated white person.

A mere blog made me realize a fundamental truth about myself - that I was more assimilated than I thought I was. I had white friends because I was just like them - I wasn't exactly the threatening picture of difference people often associated with foreigners (for example, Elvis, who came to the US in 1998, asked me what a "dreamboat" meant). All the white people thought they were being diverse and liberal by befriending someone from a different cultural background (extra brownie points because I was from a recently maligned religion and country), but in fact, they were just becoming bff with someone just like themselves.

In high school English, we learn about a hero's tragic flaw (or hamartia) in classic Greek tragedy - and I guess I found mine - hubris. I had such pride in my difference, my browness, standing proudly in a sea of white, and then I realized I wasn't so different after all. Because ultimately, you are a product of your environment, and hanging with all of these white folks had rubbed off on me.

--By Mariam, who went to Pakistan and had to experience the pitfalls of a "developing nation" for her summer vacations. Take that, white people!

10 comments:

Anna-Liisa said...

Hey, white people can have weird experiences with immigrant parents, too! Although Estonian food isn't very smelly, seeing as its mostly potatoes.

Shaz said...

I love stuffwhitepeoplelike! I never counted, but I know I enjoy a lot of stuff on that list too. I can't really comment on your experiences, but Alhamdulillah being a Muslim never ever was an issue for me growing up in England. I guess it helps that I've known my friends since I was about three or four years old, and they know me so well to the point that I asked one of them once(hypothetically) what he'd do if I asked him for some of his beer, and he said he wouldn't give me any. When I go over to their houses they make sure there's stuff I can eat etc etc. So I guess I never really felt like a foreigner. I don't really know where I'm going with this so I'll stop now.

Shaz said...

Oh yeah I remember where I was going with it! I suppose I'm as proud of being Paksitani as I am of being British. I'm grateful for both but it's not something I've ever really had to think about.

MariamQ said...

Anna-Liisa - have you seen Everything is Illuminated? Remember the part where Elijah Wood says he is a vegetarian and they give him an cooked potato? Classic!

Shiraz, that's really not how I would think it would be like growing up in England. This is actually a huge interest of mine anthropologically. Have you ever read anything by Hanif Kureishi - he paints a very different picture of the way Muslims were treated there. Also, Brick Lane is an interesting study of the way that the working-class Muslim community is segregated from mainstream society. Let me know if you want some book recs. But I am very glad to know that you have had great experiences with goras. Mahmood would say the same thing - he is more white than white people. His accent is INTENSE!

Farrah said...

If there was a list of things that foreign people like, how many of those thing would you like?
For example, Persians like:
-Designer sunglasses
-Golden Curtain Rods
-Plush Blue Carpet
-Living in California
-Talking in front of a green screen on satellite TV
-Cheesy Persian Dance Music

I only like 50% of those things, but I'm still Persian.
Now what do you think, whitey? what? WHAT?

Shaz said...

Rather than writing another comment, considering your interest in life in England I've written my own blog entry about it relating to this topic. I'd love to hear your thoughts on it (as much as you can be bothered to share) if you choose to read it.

Also, I've not read or heard of those books you mentioned. I am probably being too open, but I'm not well read at all, and I'm not intellectual so I'm not the best person to ask about stuff like that, sorry. I guess I sometimes think of things in a very selfish way, ie I often don't look at the bigger picture or society as a whole.

Thirdly, saying Mahmood's accent is intense is a HUGE understatement :)

Shaz said...

Oh and just as a warning, from an anthropological perspective, my blog entry will be of little use as it's all about one individual's personal experiences.

Aalia said...

embarrassingly, in high school i asked my friends if they considered me a white person who had a very dark and permanent tan. when they said 'yes,' i felt like i belonged. our school was extremely NOT diverse. THANK GOD i wholly embrace now the different components of who i am.

brittani c. said...

I must be a brown wannabe then. I used to tan like there was no tomorrow when I was in high school. Then somehow, my olive skin complexion gradually disappeared when I turned 21. How did that happen?
Oh, and I love plush blue carpet. That must mean that I'm part Persian. I'm going to have to take a look at that Web site and see if I'm a true whitey.

Linz said...

I only liked 35 white people things. And if that list is to be believed white people = hippie democrats. Poor uptight republicans. Where will they go? They are the whitest of all!